S h a r e
The Supreme Court judgement on motor finance and how it affects Fleet Alliance customers

Posted by
Charlie Strand
August 2025
Last week the Supreme Court ruled on three motor finance cases. The finance involved was for used cars supplied by car dealer finance brokers for a car purchase agreement.
Two of the three cases were dismissed, while the third was upheld by the Supreme Court, ruling that the finance agreement was unfair based on the Consumer Credit Act of 1974.
How does the ruling affect Fleet Alliance customers?
There is no impact on Fleet Alliance customers. We act as a credit broker not a lender or car dealer. We currently arrange rental hire agreements in the business-to-business market rather than the consumer sector, so we fall out of scope.
What about the recently announced FCA redress scheme for finance companies?
The FCA redress scheme involves finance companies and car finance brokers.
“The FCA’s redress consultation is focused on unfair lender-borrower relationships under the Consumer Credit Act, which does not apply to our firm as a broker arranging hire agreements,” commented Head of Compliance, Lynda Gibson.
“Nonetheless, we will continue to follow developments closely and remain compliant with the current FCA procedure based on some of our historic finance agreements. Our Commission Disclosure and consent process remains aligned with FCA expectations and the Consumer Duty,” added Gibson.
Should you wish to discuss the ruling, please arrange a callback here, and a member of our team will be in touch with you shortly.
You also might like…
If you liked this article then check out our posts about similar topics
The cheapest new car in Britain is now electric – and that changes the conversation
For years, the argument against electric cars has been fairly simple: they are good in theory, expensive in practice Th...
Five fleet management tips for large fleets
Fleet management has changed beyond recognition since the days when the main priority was keeping CO2 below a single tax...
BYD Sealion 7 First Drive: Making Waves in the EV SUV Market
BYD’s growth in the UK has been nothing short of explosive Having entered the market as a relative newcomer in 2023, t...
Best company cars to beat BIK in 2026/2027
For company car drivers, choosing the right vehicle can make a significant difference to monthly tax costs In the 2026/2...
HR Director’s Guide to EV Salary Sacrifice: Employee Benefits, Retention and Engagement
For HR Directors, a successful benefits strategy has to do more than look good on paper It needs to help attract tale...
Finance Director’s Guide to EV Salary Sacrifice: Cost, Risk and Early Termination
For many Finance Directors, an employee car benefit immediately raises practical questions What will it cost the busi...
What’s happened to the issue of driver safety?
Corporate Manslaughter and Duty of Care At one stage it dominated fleet thinking, especially when the Corporate Manslaug...
Electrified GV70 First Drive: Genesis Has That Invisible Touch
First impressions: Macan vibes, minus the Stuttgart invoice There’s a very specific kind of double-take the Genesis...
Ready to make the management of your fleet more efficient?
Request a call back